Silent Movie Heroin of The Late 1900s

Most films are really little more than stage plays with more atmosphere and action. I think that the scope and flexibility of movie stories would be greatly enhanced by borrowing something from the structure of silent movies where points that didn’t require dialog could be presented by a shot and a title card. Something like: Title: Billy’s uncle. Picture: Uncle giving Billy ice cream. In a few seconds, you could introduce Billy’s uncle and say something about him without being burdened with a scene. This economy of statement gives silent movies a much greater narrative scope and flexibility than we have today. 

  — Stanley Kubrick, 1981

For example, this well known 1997 silent work.

I’m not saying Kubrick’s wrong. I suspect there has instead been a return to silent movie techniques. Soon after this quote, Kubrick flags advertisements for their similar power and concision, and elsewhere he defends the use of voiceovers in Barry Lyndon. Music videos can arguably be put in a similar category. As a side effect of the commercial relevance of such things, directors of the last twenty years are trained with a cinematic toolkit shared with silent films. It is a kind of marvelous revival in disguise.

Boyle’s style has been described as a long music video – which could, at a stretch, also apply to something like Lang’s Metropolis.

In another fun parallel, there’s an innovative use of subtitling in the very metropolitan Slumdog Millionaire. Instead of confining himself to the bottom strip of screen Boyle inserts colourful inter-titles at visual locations that serve the construction of the shot.

When our ancestors – silent movies – the first time they watched locomotive trains pass across the screen they screamed. — Danny Boyle

Advertisements

One thought on “Silent Movie Heroin of The Late 1900s

  1. This is how it comes through in google/reader;

    When our ancestors – silent movies – the first time they watched locomotive trains pass across the screen they screamed. — Danny Boyle

    Like this:

    Be the first to like this post.

    Which makes the like this call to action appear part of the narrative of your blog post. I was trying to work out how ‘like this’ worked in as sarcasm or facetiously. Ended up visiting your site to see if it was just a button.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s